When selecting a professional for acupuncture services please consider the following differences between credentials of licensed acupuncturists and other professionals:
Please visit the National Certification Commission for Acupuncture & Oriental Medicine website to locate a practitioner:
http://www.nccaom.org/visitors/consumers/
You may have also heard about professionals performing dry needling and have asked yourself, “Is Dry Needling The Same As Acupuncture?” Below are some excellent resources for review, that will help differentiate between the two services:
http://www.liveoakacupuncture.com/dry-needling
http://www.nccaom.org/resource-center/press/press-releases/aama-policy-on-dry-needling/
“Dry Needling, Missing the Point” a viewpoint by Joel Thielen
As Dubuque’s First Licensed Acupuncturist, I was somewhat surprised by the content in an article posted online titled, Dry Needling by Physical Therapists Ignites Turf War With Acupuncturists. It seemed to be an unbalanced viewpoint on the practice of dry needling by physical therapists. “Dry Needling” by definition, is an invasive medical procedure in which an acupuncture needle is inserted into a specific target of soft tissue in order to improve or restore function and/or control pain. The term “dry needling” is used to differentiate this procedure from injections performed with a variety of injectables such as procaine, lidocaine, serotonin antagonists, etc. Injection therapy was used beginning in the 1940’s to treat myofascial pain. Dr. Janet Travel used many different medications and compounds injected into trigger points (painful areas) with good effect. Later it was discovered that needling the trigger points with a hypodermic needle and no injection, had the same positive results, thus dry needling came into being. Dr. Travel was a medical doctor and was using hypodermic needles to perform “dry needling”.
Today the use of acupuncture needles, to perform dry needling is not a turf war, but a clear infringement on an Acupuncturist’s scope of practice. The FDA regulates acupuncture needles as a Class II medical device subject to FDA prescription regulations and has been explicit that the sale of acupuncture needles “must be clearly restricted to qualified practitioners of Acupuncture as determined by states (61 Federal Regulation 64 616). Acupuncturists are extensively trained in Western biomedicine and take competency tests and national board exams in Western biomedicine. About 50% of an acupuncturists education is in Western biomedicine. The Chinese medical system and Western biomedical model are identical, simply different languages. Chinese Medicine was brought into alignment with Western biomedicine in the early 1950’s.
There are many arguments stating “dry needling” is not acupuncture yet the treatment of painful trigger points in Chinese Medicine dates back to Nei Jing Ling Shu 206 BC – 22 AD. 96 – 97% of all acupuncturists use a technique identical to dry needling. There is a clear effort to redefine identical medical procedures in an attempt to circumvent existing regulations. This might come as a surprise to many readers but there is absolutely zero oversight of the practice of dry needling, no curriculum requirements or competencies exist, and it is not taught in schools. Several separate courses are currently being taught to physical therapists and other allied health professionals, one by a licensed acupuncturist; and no clinical supervision is included. The insertion and removal of needles is not a procedure that can be mastered in a 16 hour weekend course no matter your background. Keep in mind eight states require medical doctors to do an additional 200-300 hours of training, prior to being allowed to practice acupuncture.
It is concerning that there appears to be little oversight by many physical therapy boards when it comes to the further expansion of the use of acupuncture needles and needling procedures. The primary purpose of medical boards is the protection of public safety. Scope of practice expansion would be moving from hypodermic needles to acupuncture needles, or from trigger point needling to distal point needling. There seems to be a disregard for the regulated, licensed practice of acupuncture, which is regulated by the Iowa Board of Medicine. Physical therapists online share information about an interesting publication by Yun-Tao-Ma titled Biomedical Acupuncture for Sports and Trauma Rehabilitation, which describes 24 “acu-reflex points” and trigger points that have “homeostatic” action to be used by the practitioners of dry needling. The issue here is there is already a form of acupuncture called Medical Acupuncture, which is regulated at the state level, by boards of medicine. Dry needling, by definition, and by practice is Acupuncture. Japanese acupuncture is superficial dry needling. Chan Gunn introduced a type of dry needling that moved away from using intramuscular trigger points. Over 93% of the points he used were documented acupuncture points.
Fourteen of fifty state physical therapy boards have determined dry needling to be within the scope of practice of a physical therapist. Many states have not ruled and some like Iowa take positions that “do not preclude a physical therapist from performing dry needling”. Jan 2, 2014, the Utah Department of Occupational and Professional Licensing proclaimed “dry needling is acupuncture”. Seven states specifically prohibit the use of “dry needling by physical therapists”. Sports trainers, chiropractors and massage therapists are now taking the 16 hour weekend courses in “dry needling” and performing the invasive procedure because as they claim, it is not acupuncture, and is not regulated as acupuncture. Since when can we rebrand an existing medical procedure, rename FDA cleared medical devices for other unapproved purposes, circumvent all oversight, and bill insurance as a manual therapy? Improvement and evolution within the different fields of medicine should be encouraged, but we need to respect regulations put in place to protect the public from harm.
There are real risks associated with the use of acupuncture needles by physical therapists and other allied health professionals who lack the education and supervised clinical training of Licensed Acupuncturists. Canadian Olympian Kim Ribble-Orr had her lung collapsed from dry needling, leaving it permanently damaged. Licensed acupuncturists are required to pass extensive competency tests, and complete 1950-4200 hours of post graduate training. The article in the Telegraph Herald has spurred me to write this viewpoint and reconvene the Iowa Acupuncture Association. We will continue to protect our scope of practice and are currently working with the Iowa Board of Medicine for review.
Joel Thielen, L.Ac., Dipl. Ac., BCIM
